Thousands of Zodiac seats subject of FAA proposed AD

US FAA officials are proposing to issue an airworthiness directive (AD) for the removal of certain aircraft seat components produced by Zodiac Seats California LLC, after determining that over 10,000 seating systems “may cause serious injury to the occupant during forward impacts when subjected to certain inertia forces”.

The proposed AD applies to Zodiac seating systems with model numbers 4157, 4170 and 4184, and are installed on a number of different aircraft types, including Boeing 717-200s, Bombardier CRJ700s, CRJ900s and Q400s, Embraer ERJ-145s, E170s and E190s. Some 10,482 seating systems are affected, and the FAA estimates that compliance with the AD will cost nearly $890, 970.

kontron newest“The impact of the head onto a typical transport passenger seat back during seat qualification testing normally results in an initial contact followed by an unimpeded sliding motion down the back of the seat. That type of interaction does not typically result in excessive neck loading or direct concentrated loading on the neck. The design of the affected seating systems introduce new injury mechanisms such that the chin can catch on the seat, causing high neck bending loads and direct concentrated loading on the neck. This interaction between the head and the seat during forward impacts can result in serious injury to the occupant,” explains the FAA in a notice of proposed rulemaking sourced by contributing writer Jason Rabinowitz.

Airlines will have 60 months to implement the fix after a final AD is issued. The FAA says seating systems may be removed from service for the purpose of performing maintenance activities and reinstalled on airplanes operated by the same operator, if the operator complies with the removal of affected seating systems. New seating systems may also be installed as direct spares for the same part number seating systems “but only until the operator complies with the removal of affected seating systems required” in the proposed AD.

Zodiac could not be immediately reached for comment. The company has grappled with seat delays and other issues in recent years, with Airbus in January suggesting it had removed Zodiac from its A330neo catalogue.

5 Comments

  1. Seth Miller

    This is going to cost WAY more than a million dollars to fix. That estimate is just for removing the seats from the aircraft where currently installed (1 hour each @ $85/hour * 10k+ units); it does not cover the necessary cost of acquiring and installing new seats.

    Also gotta wonder how the heck they were approved in the first place. Did the FAA not run the tests then??

  2. Pingback: Multiple US airlines affected by FAA directive on Zodiac seats - Wandering Aramean

  3. Juan Septiano

    Indeed, it seems like an oversight to me. However, I am not expecting it to become an AD soon — there are other NPRMs on more critical systems that are still stuck as NPRM, even after 5 years.

    Also, 5 years of compliance time is quite generous. In the meantime, if Zodiac could come up with a cheaper solution, they may propose an AMOC or provide reasons for the AD to be superseded. Even better, the airlines/operators might have rejuvenated their fleet by then, thus getting rid of the affected seats altogether.

  4. Raflw

    I don’t know how many of the sets are in E145s, but they are on the way out, and this could set a deadline for those aircraft. It seems like Q400s are parking, too. And some CR7 flying may be curtailed by then as well. Depends on the fuel price environment as well as regional pilot shortage issues (I did read recently that Aspen Pitkin is worried about CR7 retirements as there isn’t an economically viable, operationally compatible aircraft as CR7s leave the market. KInda off topic but relevant if seating issues accelerate retirements).

  5. Pingback: [Actualité] Quelle issue pour Zodiac Aerospace ? – Tyler Birth